Principle ApplicationDiff: Medium
Logic Breakdown
Passage Summary: Vanessa thinks every programmer must work with a partner so the code is easy to understand. Jo thinks the best programmers are much faster alone and should be allowed to work by themselves.
Reasoning: Vanessa requires all code to be written in pairs to ensure clarity, while Jo requires the most productive programmers to work alone to maximize their efficiency.
Analysis: This Principle Application question asks for the one scenario that violates at least one of the two rules. Vanessa's rule is a universal 'all,' meaning no one can ever work alone. Jo's rule is a 'must' for a specific group: the most productive programmers. The conflict is clear: if a 'most productive' programmer is assigned to a project, Vanessa says they need a partner, but Jo says they must be alone. To find the 'EXCEPT' answer, look for a situation where a top-tier programmer is paired up (violating Jo) or any programmer is left alone (violating Vanessa).
Reasoning: Vanessa requires all code to be written in pairs to ensure clarity, while Jo requires the most productive programmers to work alone to maximize their efficiency.
Analysis: This Principle Application question asks for the one scenario that violates at least one of the two rules. Vanessa's rule is a universal 'all,' meaning no one can ever work alone. Jo's rule is a 'must' for a specific group: the most productive programmers. The conflict is clear: if a 'most productive' programmer is assigned to a project, Vanessa says they need a partner, but Jo says they must be alone. To find the 'EXCEPT' answer, look for a situation where a top-tier programmer is paired up (violating Jo) or any programmer is left alone (violating Vanessa).
Passage Stimulus
Passage Redacted
Unlock Full Passage18.Each of the following assignments of computer programmers is consistent both with the principle expressed by Vanessa and with the principle expressed by Jo EXCEPT:
Correct Answer
D
D pairs the team’s most productive programmer with another programmer. That directly violates Jo’s principle (the most productive must be allowed to work alone), even though it satisfies Vanessa’s pairing rule. Hence it is not consistent with both.
Upgrade Your Prep
Ready to go beyond free explanations?
LSAT Perfection is the #1 modern LSAT prep platform, trusted by thousands of students for comprehensive test strategies, advanced drilling, and full analytics on every PrepTest.
Detailed explanations for 59 PrepTests
Advanced drillset builder
Personalized analytics
Built-in Wrong Answer Journal