Flawed ReasoningDiff: Easy
Logic Breakdown
Passage Summary: A parent complains about unfair punishment; the principal tries to excuse the school's choice by comparing it to an accidental traffic jam.
Conclusion: The principal implies that punishing the entire class is an acceptable or unavoidable consequence.
Reasoning: The principal uses an analogy of a traffic jam—an unintended physical consequence—to justify a deliberate disciplinary decision made by school authorities.
Analysis: This argument falls into the trap of a 'False Analogy' by comparing two things that aren't actually comparable in terms of agency. A traffic jam is a spontaneous, unintended result of an accident, whereas a school's decision to take away recess is a calculated, human-made policy. The principal is essentially trying to treat a conscious choice as if it were an act of nature. Look for an answer that highlights this shift from an involuntary occurrence to a voluntary action.
Conclusion: The principal implies that punishing the entire class is an acceptable or unavoidable consequence.
Reasoning: The principal uses an analogy of a traffic jam—an unintended physical consequence—to justify a deliberate disciplinary decision made by school authorities.
Analysis: This argument falls into the trap of a 'False Analogy' by comparing two things that aren't actually comparable in terms of agency. A traffic jam is a spontaneous, unintended result of an accident, whereas a school's decision to take away recess is a calculated, human-made policy. The principal is essentially trying to treat a conscious choice as if it were an act of nature. Look for an answer that highlights this shift from an involuntary occurrence to a voluntary action.
Passage Stimulus
Passage Redacted
Unlock Full Passage2.The principal's response to Ms. Smith's complaint is most vulnerable to criticism on which one of the following grounds?
Correct Answer
C
It identifies the central disanalogy: traffic-jam suffering is unavoidable, whereas the classwide punishment was avoidable and chosen. The principal’s analogy doesn’t address this, making the reasoning vulnerable.
Upgrade Your Prep
Ready to go beyond free explanations?
LSAT Perfection is the #1 modern LSAT prep platform, trusted by thousands of students for comprehensive test strategies, advanced drilling, and full analytics on every PrepTest.
Detailed explanations for 59 PrepTests
Advanced drillset builder
Personalized analytics
Built-in Wrong Answer Journal