Method of ReasoningDiff: Easy
Logic Breakdown
Passage Summary: Sheila argues that colorizing old movies is fine because it's like turning a book into a movie—it's a new version that doesn't change the original one bit.
Conclusion: Colorizing a black-and-white film is an acceptable practice that does not harm the original work's integrity.
Reasoning: Just as a movie based on a book is a separate entity that doesn't diminish the book's value, a colorized film is a new, distinct work that should be judged independently of the original.
Analysis: Sheila's method is centered on the use of an analogy to justify a controversial practice. She attempts to neutralize the 'integrity' argument by pointing to a similar, widely accepted scenario where a derivative work exists alongside an original without conflict. When evaluating the answer choices, look for descriptions of 'argument by analogy' or 'drawing a parallel.' It’s a classic 'if you’re okay with X, you should be okay with Y' maneuver that relies on the two situations being functionally identical in the relevant ways.
Conclusion: Colorizing a black-and-white film is an acceptable practice that does not harm the original work's integrity.
Reasoning: Just as a movie based on a book is a separate entity that doesn't diminish the book's value, a colorized film is a new, distinct work that should be judged independently of the original.
Analysis: Sheila's method is centered on the use of an analogy to justify a controversial practice. She attempts to neutralize the 'integrity' argument by pointing to a similar, widely accepted scenario where a derivative work exists alongside an original without conflict. When evaluating the answer choices, look for descriptions of 'argument by analogy' or 'drawing a parallel.' It’s a classic 'if you’re okay with X, you should be okay with Y' maneuver that relies on the two situations being functionally identical in the relevant ways.
Passage Stimulus
Passage Redacted
Unlock Full Passage2.Sheila's argument uses which one of the following techniques of argumentation?
Correct Answer
A
Sheila builds and relies on an analogy: film adaptations don’t harm the value of the original books, so colorized films likewise shouldn’t be seen as damaging the integrity of the original black-and-white films.
Upgrade Your Prep
Ready to go beyond free explanations?
LSAT Perfection is the #1 modern LSAT prep platform, trusted by thousands of students for comprehensive test strategies, advanced drilling, and full analytics on every PrepTest.
Detailed explanations for 59 PrepTests
Advanced drillset builder
Personalized analytics
Built-in Wrong Answer Journal