Principle JustifyDiff: Hardest
Logic Breakdown
Passage Summary: A sociologist argues that institutions can't make people evil because institutions are just made up of people in the first place.
Conclusion: The theory that people are born good but corrupted by institutions is incorrect.
Reasoning: Institutions are nothing more than groups of people, so the causal influence must flow from the people to the institution, not the other way around.
Analysis: The sociologist's argument has a gap: it assumes that a collective entity (an institution) cannot have an effect on its members that is different from the nature of the members themselves. To justify this, we need a principle that reinforces this 'part-to-whole' relationship. Look for a rule stating that a group cannot possess any quality or exert any influence that does not originate from the individuals within it. This would bridge the gap between the composition of the institution and its inability to change human nature.
Conclusion: The theory that people are born good but corrupted by institutions is incorrect.
Reasoning: Institutions are nothing more than groups of people, so the causal influence must flow from the people to the institution, not the other way around.
Analysis: The sociologist's argument has a gap: it assumes that a collective entity (an institution) cannot have an effect on its members that is different from the nature of the members themselves. To justify this, we need a principle that reinforces this 'part-to-whole' relationship. Look for a rule stating that a group cannot possess any quality or exert any influence that does not originate from the individuals within it. This would bridge the gap between the composition of the institution and its inability to change human nature.
Passage Stimulus
Passage Redacted
Unlock Full Passage24.Which one of the following principles, if valid, would most help to justify the sociologist's argument?
Correct Answer
E
E states the needed principle: the whole does not determine the properties of its components. Given institutions are “collections of people,” this principle supports the sociologist’s claim that institutions cannot make people evil.
Upgrade Your Prep
Ready to go beyond free explanations?
LSAT Perfection is the #1 modern LSAT prep platform, trusted by thousands of students for comprehensive test strategies, advanced drilling, and full analytics on every PrepTest.
Detailed explanations for 59 PrepTests
Advanced drillset builder
Personalized analytics
Built-in Wrong Answer Journal