Argument EvaluationDiff: Hardest
Logic Breakdown
Passage Summary: Franklin thinks Miller is innocent of a prank because the handwriting on the note isn't hers, even though she had a motive to do it.
Conclusion: The person responsible for the practical joke is likely someone other than Miller.
Reasoning: The only evidence available is the handwriting on a note, and that handwriting does not match Miller's.
Analysis: Franklin’s logic is a bit naive because it assumes the handwriting on the note must be the joker's natural, undisguised writing. In the world of practical jokes, it is quite common for someone to disguise their script or have an accomplice write the note to throw people off the scent. The argument fails to consider that the 'only clue' might be a deliberate red herring. When evaluating this, look for an answer that points out the possibility of the evidence being manipulated or misleading.
Conclusion: The person responsible for the practical joke is likely someone other than Miller.
Reasoning: The only evidence available is the handwriting on a note, and that handwriting does not match Miller's.
Analysis: Franklin’s logic is a bit naive because it assumes the handwriting on the note must be the joker's natural, undisguised writing. In the world of practical jokes, it is quite common for someone to disguise their script or have an accomplice write the note to throw people off the scent. The argument fails to consider that the 'only clue' might be a deliberate red herring. When evaluating this, look for an answer that points out the possibility of the evidence being manipulated or misleading.
Passage Stimulus
Passage Redacted
Unlock Full Passage14.Which one of the following provides the strongest grounds for criticizing Franklin's reasoning?
Correct Answer
A
A is correct because if there was more than one practical joker, the handwriting not matching Miller’s does not rule out Miller’s involvement; thus Franklin’s conclusion that the joker is someone else is not justified.
Upgrade Your Prep
Ready to go beyond free explanations?
LSAT Perfection is the #1 modern LSAT prep platform, trusted by thousands of students for comprehensive test strategies, advanced drilling, and full analytics on every PrepTest.
Detailed explanations for 59 PrepTests
Advanced drillset builder
Personalized analytics
Built-in Wrong Answer Journal