Point at IssueDiff: Medium

Logic Breakdown

Passage Summary: Mario and Lucy are debating the definition of an 'autonomous discipline.' Mario thinks a field needs its own exclusive topics to be independent, while Lucy believes independence comes from having a unique way of investigating topics, regardless of whether those topics are shared.

Reasoning: Mario claims autonomy requires a unique domain of inquiry; Lucy claims it requires a unique methodology and rejects Mario's exclusion of cognitive science.

Analysis: Apply the 'Agree/Disagree' test to find the point of contention. Mario explicitly states that a unique domain of inquiry is a requirement for autonomy, whereas Lucy explicitly rejects this, favoring methodology instead. They also clearly disagree on the status of cognitive science itself. Look for an answer choice that presents a statement where Mario would say 'True' and Lucy would say 'False' (or vice versa), specifically regarding the necessary conditions for a discipline's autonomy.

Passage Stimulus

Passage Redacted

Unlock Full Passage

11.

On the basis of their statements, Mario and Lucy are committed to disagreeing about the truth of which one of the following?

Correct Answer
A
A states that if a field has a unique methodology but lacks a unique domain, it can still be autonomous. Lucy affirms this (her criterion), while Mario’s principle rules it out. So they are committed to opposite truth values.
Upgrade Your Prep

Ready to go beyond free explanations?

LSAT Perfection is the #1 modern LSAT prep platform, trusted by thousands of students for comprehensive test strategies, advanced drilling, and full analytics on every PrepTest.

Detailed explanations for 59 PrepTests
Advanced drillset builder
Personalized analytics
Built-in Wrong Answer Journal
Explore Perfection Plus for full LSAT prep